Proper Fish

Great Eats Award Winner

Proper Fish is a modern British-style fish & chips restaurant located at 112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110. Opened in 2019 by Harvey Wolff—originally from the celebrated Nosh food truck—it serves giant beer-battered cod filets, hand-cut fries, minty mushy peas, oysters, chowder, cocktails, and British ales in a casual, welcoming space featuring an open kitchen and outdoor seating .

how it all started.

Harvey Wolff, a London native who found fame with Seattle’s Nosh truck, chose Bainbridge Island as the permanent home for his award-winning fish & chips concept after winning accolades from the Seattle Times and Zagat . His focus: sustainably sourced Bering Sea cod, secret house beer batter crafted with local brewery flour, and meticulous preparation—serving up to 700 orders on Mother’s Day alone. The restaurant quickly became a local hit, with lines out the door since day one .

What should you Try?

Standout items that keep fans coming back:

  • British Fish & Chips: Jumbo Alaskan cod, light crispy batter, hand-cut twice-cooked fries, minted mushy peas, and tartar sauce—hailed as “Seattle’s best” by multiple outlets .

  • Fish Sandwich: Cod loin with caramelized tomatoes & onions, arugula on a buttered potato roll—a frequent dining companion to fish & chips lovers .

  • Wild Bering Sea Cod Chowder: Rich, thick, and full of flavor—pure comfort .

  • Fried Oysters & Whitebait: Lightly battered and perfectly fried, ideal for seafood lovers .

  • East Coast Lobster Roll & Prawn & Crab Cocktail: Premium seafood options that round out the menu .

Pair your meal with British ale or sparkling wine, all served with care and attention .

Location and Contact Information

  • Address: 112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110

  • Phone: (206) 855‑5051

  • Hours:

    • Tue–Thu: 11 AM–7 PM

    • Fri–Sat: 11 AM–8 PM

    • Sun–Mon: 11 AM–7 PM

  • Extras: Online ordering, catering, merch (mugs, tees), and rotating specials like brunch or English Sunday Lunch .

Related Winners

Big Sergio’s Pizza & Catering

Big Sergio’s is a local favorite for New York–style pizza, subs, calzones, pasta, and gyros. Located at 2127 Ten‑Ten Rd, Apex, NC, this casual counter-serve spot is known for its generous portions, stone‑oven pies, gluten‑free options, and friendly service with broad appeal from families to office groups

Continue Reading

Brasilia Grill

Brasilia Grill is a long‑standing Brazilian churrascaria at 99 Monroe St, Newark, NJ 07105, serving up rodízio-style barbecue since 1986. Guests are immersed in gaucho‑carved meats brought fresh from the grill to the table, paired with a bounty of hot and cold buffet options in a lively, family-friendly environment

Continue Reading