Proper Fish

Great Eats Award Winner

Proper Fish is a modern British-style fish & chips restaurant located at 112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110. Opened in 2019 by Harvey Wolff—originally from the celebrated Nosh food truck—it serves giant beer-battered cod filets, hand-cut fries, minty mushy peas, oysters, chowder, cocktails, and British ales in a casual, welcoming space featuring an open kitchen and outdoor seating .

how it all started.

Harvey Wolff, a London native who found fame with Seattle’s Nosh truck, chose Bainbridge Island as the permanent home for his award-winning fish & chips concept after winning accolades from the Seattle Times and Zagat . His focus: sustainably sourced Bering Sea cod, secret house beer batter crafted with local brewery flour, and meticulous preparation—serving up to 700 orders on Mother’s Day alone. The restaurant quickly became a local hit, with lines out the door since day one .

What should you Try?

Standout items that keep fans coming back:

  • British Fish & Chips: Jumbo Alaskan cod, light crispy batter, hand-cut twice-cooked fries, minted mushy peas, and tartar sauce—hailed as “Seattle’s best” by multiple outlets .

  • Fish Sandwich: Cod loin with caramelized tomatoes & onions, arugula on a buttered potato roll—a frequent dining companion to fish & chips lovers .

  • Wild Bering Sea Cod Chowder: Rich, thick, and full of flavor—pure comfort .

  • Fried Oysters & Whitebait: Lightly battered and perfectly fried, ideal for seafood lovers .

  • East Coast Lobster Roll & Prawn & Crab Cocktail: Premium seafood options that round out the menu .

Pair your meal with British ale or sparkling wine, all served with care and attention .

Location and Contact Information

  • Address: 112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110

  • Phone: (206) 855‑5051

  • Hours:

    • Tue–Thu: 11 AM–7 PM

    • Fri–Sat: 11 AM–8 PM

    • Sun–Mon: 11 AM–7 PM

  • Extras: Online ordering, catering, merch (mugs, tees), and rotating specials like brunch or English Sunday Lunch .

Related Winners

Thyme On Section

Thyme on Section is a modern coastal-inspired restaurant in downtown Fairhope at 33 N Section St, Fairhope, AL 36532. Opened in 2010 by chef-owners Adrian and Rachel Yots, the venue offers a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere—featuring dark wood, exposed brick, an open kitchen, full bar, and touches of Mid-century charm . The menu highlights seasonally driven, New‑American fare with Southern accents, showcasing locally sourced produce, seafood, steaks, and scratch-made small plates .

Continue Reading

Rudy’s Pub & Grill

Rudy’s Pub & Grill is a popular American sports bar and pub with two locations in Meridian: one on Overland Road and one on McMillan Road. Known for its generous portions, fresh‑ingredients menu, and lively atmosphere complete with multiple TVs, weekend sports coverage, and welcoming spaces for families and friends .

Continue Reading